There are two things that you can use here. If your dog likes a toy and a tug, I would not prefer a ball, because you can't get on to the end of it. You could put a ball on a rope and tug with that, but you want a plain tug toy, or this will turn into a tug toy.
Toys You Should Avoid With Senior Dogs - Vetstreet
WRITE IT OUT First, I would sit down and write out exactly what’s going on. What is being guarded? Toys? Food that falls on the floor? Mom’s lap? Second, what context? Outside in the yard over the wading pool? Inside in the living room over the chew toy, or in the kitchen over the dinner bowl? State exactly what the guarder does, being as detailed as you can. Does she go stiff and close her mouth before beginning to growl? Or bark and lunge with little warning? What does the other dog do? What do YOU do? This process can be tedious, but I can’t emphasize enough the importance of writing out as many details as you can. I don’t know how many times I’ve written out an issue with one of my own dogs and learned something important in the process.
Dog Agility – Training your Dog with a Toy ..
Another trick you can try is to offer your dog a much more valuable treat. Use whatever she loves most and trade her the extra special treat for the toy. You may need to use pieces of steak or chicken or hot dogs. Use whatever works. Use a command like “drop” or “leave it” and reward with the tasty treat once she does. Repeat several times a day.
Border Terrier Dog With Toy Norfolk Stock Photo | Getty Images
Mothering a toy is one thing. But tearing it to shreds? Well, some dogs with high predatory drives - - will get especially attached to toys they can really tear into. "Dogs are eternally toddlers," she says. "A human child who has a favourite toy will, at some point, reach a developmental stage where it's not appropriate to carry around a teddy bear anymore. We replace it with a charm in our pocket or a picture of a best friend in our wallet."